2010

Simone Feldman

2009

Gabrielle Carlson

2008

Casandra Tressler

2007

Michaé Holloman

2006

Melissa DiGiulian

2005

Marina Harrison

Top 10

2004

Tia Shorts

2003

Jamie Kramer

2002

Mistie Renee Adams

2001

Megan Gunning

2000

Christie S. Davis

1999

Kelly Donohue

1998

Maria Lynn Sheriff

1997

Ann Coale

1996

Michele Michael

1995

Jennifer Danielle Wilhoit

Top 12

1994

Wendy Davis

1993

Mary Ann Cimino

1992

Renee Rebstock

1991

Lisa Marie Lawson

1990

Julie Stanford

1989

Jackie Carroll

1988

Rowanne Brewer

Semi-Finalist

1987

Michelle Snow

1986

Kelly Koehler

1985

Christine Marie

1984

Betsy Cook

1983

Shawn Keller

1982

Angie Boyer

Semi-Finalist

1981

Linda Susan Lambert

Semi-Finalist

1980

Tonja Walker

Semi-Finalist

1979

Jean Bourne

1978

Rhonda Koch

1977

Twyla Littleton

1976

Linda Lee Potter

1975

Ellen Bowie

1974

Mary Jo Ruppert

1973

Betty Jo Grove

4th Runner-Up

1972

Patty Townsend

1971

Carol Jeanne Theis

Semi-Finalist

1970

Beckie Price

1969

Ardis Fowler

1968

Paulette Reck

1st Runner-Up

1967

Sandra Clevering

Semi-Finalist

1966

Roselaine Zetter

Semi-Finalist

1965

Barbara Kiefer

1964

Royette Michele Tarry

Semi-Finalist

1963

Marsha Barbara Metrinko

1962

Shelda Farley

1961

Gail Baxter

1957

Mary Leona Gage

Miss USA

1956

Charlene Holt

Semi-Finalist

1955

Gloria Ruth King

1954

Barbara Eschenburg

Semi-Finalist

1953

Diane Gale Durham

1952

Did Not Compete